THE BLOG

Stop Fighting in Your Marriage | Why Logic Always Backfires

Nov 04, 2025

If you’ve ever been in an argument with your wife that felt like you were in the Daytona 500, just hours of endless circles, you probably tried to use your logic to fix it.


You laid out the facts, you explained your side, and expected her to meet you halfway.

But instead… she got more emotional and upset at you, the conversation blew up to another fight,  and you were left thinking, “What just happened? Everything I said made sense and was the truth.”

In this video, I’m going to break down why logic almost always backfires when you’re trying to stop fighting in your relationship and  what to do instead so you keep the peace, your sanity, and help strengthen your leadership in the marriage to open your wife up to a place of happy, healthy reconnection again.

Before we jump in, if you have just been fighting constantly and your marriage is boiling to the point of unbearable stress and close to the brink of divorce being a serious possibility,  

I have a free masterclass that will walk you through the exact step-by-step framework I teach those who are in my Relationship Rebuild program.

Click the link in the description below. I highly encourage you to watch that, for free, after this video.

For now, let’s get you on the right track fast to make your relationship better.

 

The Cost of “Winning” with Logic

Men are generally raised, and it is our natural mentality, to solve problems by reasoning through them.

That’s how we handle healthy conflict with other men - we debate, exchange facts, find the best solution, and for the most part, move on.

But emotional conflict with a woman doesn’t follow that same system.

When you try to win an argument with your wife through logic, what she hears, at a subconscious level, is:

“He’s trying to win or make me look dumb, not connect with me.”

And when a woman feels that, she emotionally withdraws. She’s not listening to your logic anymore. She’s defending her sense of safety.

In your eyes, you’re thinking, hey… “I’m just explaining my side.”

But she’s in her eyes, she feels like, “He doesn’t get how I feel.”

That gap is the invisible wall that often becomes a carbon monoxide lead in a marriage, it just slowly and unsuspectingly kills emotional safety.


And once that safety disappears, logic becomes noise and this is where men run into their biggest marriage challenges.

This was one of my biggest struggles for so long with women in my romantic relationships because I am a very logical and rational guy.

Back then, I had no clue how women actually worked emotionally… It was a repetitive recipe for disaster in my love life. 

Anytime I would be in an argument, I would present what I thought were logical facts. 

Whether it was my long-term girlfriend when I was younger, my ex-fiance, or anybody I was dating shorter term, these conversations would always go the same.

Logic would be completely ignored on their end and they would get increasingly upset and frustrated, which would make me increasingly frustrated and mad because I couldn’t understand why they would ignore simple logic.

So it would be the same fights. And finally after over a decade, and the last straw being my ex-fiance leaving me, I had to come to the realization that I fundamentally did not understand women and I was clearly doing many things wrong - it wasn’t a coincidence. 

 

Emotional Flooding: The Real Enemy

The reason logic doesn’t work is because your wife isn’t in her logical brain during conflict.

When emotions are high, the body releases cortisol and adrenaline, and her nervous system shifts into protection mode.

It’s not that she doesn’t necessarily understand the logical points and reasoning that you’re saying, it’s that her brain is literally prioritizing survival over giving a crap if what you are saying makes completely perfect sense.

So every time you bring up “facts,” you’re talking to the part of her that’s not even active right now.

And before you start to think that it makes it seem like it is impossible to have a good marriage with your wife because of this huge difference, you need to know that MEN DO THIS AS WELL. 

It just looks slightly different.  When you’re giving your unbelievably accurate facts and the more she isn’t listening the more you get frustrated,  you also start to emotionally flood, you just show it differently.


You might go quiet, get sarcastic, double down on logic (but this time presenting it even louder or more angrily) to regain control and FORCE her to see your points.

This is the massive disconnect. Two flooded nervous systems trying to argue facts.

This is how everything just escalates into a big fight because at this point it’s not communication, it’s two defense systems colliding.

 

Lead Her Away From The Flooding

So if this is happening to you in your relationship, where do you go from here?

Well I firmly believe the only choice you have in order to make your relationship thrive is for you to lead the emotional climate.

That doesn’t mean suppressing your feelings because you don’t want to upset her, but it means staying grounded so that she can follow you in that regard.

Leadership in moments of tension is not about who’s right, it’s about who’s regulated. As soon as you get angry and tension mounts because your logical points are being ignored by her, your power and ability to lead your wife and have her respect disappears.

When you shift from trying to prove something to trying to create safety, the entire tone of the conflict changes.

You stop speaking to her mind because you understand her nervous system, so you start speaking to it instead.

So what does that really look like?

Here’s an example:
Instead of saying,

“That’s not what happened — you’re exaggerating,”
you could say,

 “I get that it felt that way for you. I don’t see it the same, but I understand why that would hurt.”

That’s validating her feelings without disintegrating your own logical points.

It keeps you authentic, but it softens her defenses.
It is only when you start to create safety that she can hear you again.

 

The Calm Masculine Presence

Your calmness doesn’t just de-escalate her emotions, what it helps to really do is re-establish polarity in your relationship dynamic, which is incredibly important for attraction and respect.

In a fight, polarity tends to disappear because both people move into frustrating modes of control, logic, dominance, or defense.

When you stay grounded and actually show up as as a calm, strong, masculine presence, that is signaling that the relationship is safe

When she is upset,  you’re not matching her chaos to go down the road of escalation. 

And that’s the difference between a man who wins arguments but loses the overall war,  and a man who leads her to a safe emotional state and wins her trust back.

Here’s the paradox: you think she wants you to understand her point in these situations, but what she really wants is to feel that you can handle her emotions and that you validate her without counterattacking.

That’s emotional leadership.

 

The “Loop” That Keeps You Stuck

Many men stuck in marriage conflicts are caught in what I call the FPF Loop. The “Fix-Prove-Fight Loop.”

  1. She gets emotional.

  2. You feel attacked.

  3. You explain or defend logically.

  4. She feels dismissed and gets more emotional.

  5. You shut down OR double down in annoyance and frustration, and push harder with facts (like I used to do endlessly, it was my kryptonite).

  6. The cycle repeats and intimacy dies one argument at a time.

Breaking that loop doesn’t come from better arguments or “listening better” as some advice will tell you. 

Because you can listen more attentively (which yes, ultimately you should when communicating) — but when it’s your turn to respond and all you do is again push logic and facts while invalidating the emotions she is feeling, you’re going to end up with your wife getting the same disconnected feeling but maybe there wasn’t yelling, cutting her off, or loud voices.

No, breaking the FPF Loop comes from breaking the pattern inside you.

You have to realize that you can't control her emotional reactions, but you can control whether you lead the moment or react to it yourself, which compounds the problem and is not leadership...

 

The Way Out: Create Emotional Safety First

A counterintuitive aspect of healthy relationships that I would say 90+% of men do not understand is that when a woman feels safe, she starts reconnecting naturally.

You don’t have to “try harder” and do all of these over the top things to convince her to reconnect, this becomes a natural response to your leadership and creates a safe environment for her emotions. 

She stops trying to win and starts wanting to understand you more because you’ve contained her emotions, validated them, and are able to convey your logical points that will be respected more because you’ve done your part first..

So next time a conversation is happening and it is looking like it could head the way of another same ol fight,
instead of defending yourself, do this:

  1.  Don’t fire back. Take a moment to remind yourself, “This is not an attack. This is a pain trying to be understood.”

  2. And then, instead of thinking of other ways to present your logical points so she understands, think to yourself “What is she actually needing to feel safe right now?”
    Usually it’s reassurance that you care, and validating her emotions, even when you disagree about the meat and potatoes points in the conversation. .

  3. And when you take that time to first create that safety and validation for her, THEN you can respond (NOT REACT).

 You can say something like:  “I get that this is frustrating. I care about fixing it, not fighting.”

That one phrase  “I care about fixing it, not fighting” disarms her. It turns what could be another argument leading to a big fight, into a partnership moment.

And that’s how marriages start to heal, not through perfection, not through a nice Cartier bracelet, but through you willing to show up and lead calmly in the chaos.

 

I do want to make one thing clear: you’re not responsible for your wife’s emotions. 

But you are responsible for the emotional environment you help create.

When you bring a calm, masculine tone into moments of tension, you’re telling her nervous system, it’s safe to come down and that you’re not the enemy.

And when that becomes your consistent pattern, conflict stops feeling like threat and starts feeling like connection.

That’s when her guard drops and the space for attraction to rebuild and her to reconnect stronger opens again..

The Hope

If you’re in a place right now where every conversation feels like it could turn into, or DOES turn into, another argument and big fight, I want you to know — it’s not a hopeless situation.

I’ve worked with men who were sleeping in separate bedrooms, feeling invisible,
believing the damage was permanent and that they would never get out of this cycle. .

And when they learned to lead differently when they stopped trying to win, and started to create safety, their marriages didn’t just survive, they were elevated to places untouched previously.

These men started to approach life in a completely different way and the level of respect their wives had for them returned naturally.

Your marriage can absolutely heal  but it won’t happen through logic.

It happens through understanding how to show up as the leader after years of complacency, and learning all the counterintuitive aspects of how a woman’s nervous system truly operates.

 

Conclusion

If this is hitting close to home, if you’re tired of trying to talk things through logically and just getting into the same fights over and over, where it just feels your wife has completely disconnected from you, you don’t have to figure this out alone.

I walk men through this exact transformation inside my free masterclass, where I’ll show you the  5-step process that’s saving marriages every week in my Relationship Rebuild program.

You’ll learn how to rebuild her respect, her trust, and her emotional attraction, and completely transform your life without having to beg her to work with you or tell you what she needs. 

You can do this transformation through your own commitment to change.

The link for the free masterclass is in the description below. Watch it today.

Also, if you liked this video has helped you, please hit the like button and subscribe to the channel.

I’ll see you in the next episode.

Take Me To The FREE Masterclass